
After a wildly successful regular season in which they finished with baseball's best record (98-64), the Angels were unceremoniously swept out of the ALDS by the Royals. They'll go back to drawing board this offseason and try to get over the hump next year. Time to review the Angels' season.
What went right
In all likelihood, Mike Trout will be named the AL MVP next month even though 2014 was the worst of his three full MLB seasons. He was still excellent, of course, hitting 36 home runs with a 167 OPS+ and an MLB-leading 7.9 WAR. Trout is the best all-around player in baseball and he just turned 23 in August. He's everything that is right with the Halos.
The Angels also watched Kole Calhoun break out to become an impact leadoff hitter and Albert Pujols rebound to be an above-average first baseman (though not all the way back to the Albert Pujols of old). Garrett Richards emerged as an ace before a knee injury ended his season prematurely. Unheralded rookie Matt Shoemaker came up from the minors and won 16 games in 20 starts (and seven relief appearances) to give the club a much-needed shot in the arm.
The bullpen was a clear weakness coming into the season but GM Jerry Dipoto used his limited financial -- the Angels are bumping up against the luxury tax threshold and reportedly do not want to go over -- and farm system resources to add Huston Street, Jason Grilli, Vinnie Pestano and Joe Thatcher at the trade deadline. Rookie Mike Morin also came up from the minors to have an impact out of the bullpen. Dipoto did a great job turning that bullpen into a strength at midseason.
What went wrong
Rotation depth was a season-long problem that was never really addressed. Richards was outstanding until he got hurt and Shoemaker was fantastic, plus Jered Weaver was his usual rock solid self, but C.J. Wilson had a poor year and the hodgepodge of fill-ins (Hector Santiago, Cory Rasmus, Wade LeBlanc) were not the answer. Tyler Skaggs was having a nice year until he blew out his elbow and needed Tommy John surgery at midseason. The Angels went into the postseason with only two reliable starters in Weaver and Shoemaker, and Shoemaker was coming off an oblique injury.
Josh Hamilton hit 10 home runs with a 114 OPS+ in 89 games while battling a litany of injuries, meaning the club generally had no power from the left side other than Calhoun. Depth in general was an issue, an issue that stems from having the consensus worst farm system in baseball coming into the season. The Angels relied on too many John McDonalds and J.B. Shucks and Ian Stewarts and Brennan Boeschs throughout the year.
MVP: Trout. By a mile. Next question.
LVP: Either Hamilton or Wilson. I'll say Wilson because at least Hamilton has the injury excuse. Wilson had a 4.51 ERA (81 ERA+) and a 1.45 WHIP in 175 2/3 innings during the regular season, putting him at exactly replacement level (0 WAR). Then, of course, he got bombed in ALDS Game 3 and did not make it out of the first inning.
Free agents to be: RHP Huston Street ($7 million club option), RHP Jason Grilli, LHP Sean Burnett ($4.5 million club option), LHP Joe Thatcher
Gameplan heading into the offseason
The Angels currently have ten players under contract at a total of $130 million in 2015 counting Street's no-brainer option (but not Burnett), leaving a good amount of wiggle room under the $189 million luxury tax threshold. Richards will get a nice raise through arbitration, though not enough to derail their offseason spending ability.
The Halos will likely avoid big pitching free agents like Max Scherzer, Jon Lester and James Shields, any of whom would be an enormous upgrade to the rotation. A lower cost free agent like Brandon McCarthy or Francisco Liriano (or both!) makes more sense. Eating money to trade Wilson could be on the table. He had a very good season in 2013 and is owed $38 million from 2015-16. Would eating $15 million to $20 million to deal him make sense? I guess it depends on the return.
The core of the Angels is in place. They're built around Trout, Pujols, Hamilton, Calhoun, Howie Kendrick, Erick Aybar, Weaver, Wilson, Richards and Shoemaker going forward whether they like it or not. They'll spend the winter looking to fill out the margins of the roster. Because the farm system is weak, expect them to aggressively target minor league free agents for Triple-A depth. It has to come from somewhere. This will surely be an interesting winter in Anaheim. No doubt about it.
Ridiculously premature prediction for 2015
The Angels had nine regulars with an OPS+ over 100 this year and all nine guys are either signed or under control for next year, so the best offense in baseball in terms of runs per game (4.77) will remain intact in 2015. Whether they perform like that again remains to be seen. Dipoto will make some smaller pitching additions, stock the cupboard, and the Angels will again be the best team in the AL West next season. They'll win the division and be in much better shape for the postseason with a more well-rounded roster.









